Insights

Private Infrastructure: An Asset Class for All Economic Conditions

  • 5 minute read
Dark mode saves between 3% - 6% energy. By reducing energy consumption we could help minimize damage to the environment.

Infrastructure has become a favored asset class in recent years given its outperformance in high-volatility periods like 2022 and its overall ability to provide alpha, yield, an inflation hedge, and a cushion against economic shocks. Our research suggests that private infrastructure:

  • Has historically demonstrated strong performance relative to other asset classes through the economic cycle ,
  • Offers an effective hedge against inflation , as we saw in 2021-2023, but also delivers a robust cash yield in low-rate environments,
  • Tends to exhibit relatively low volatility , particularly when broader markets are turbulent or dislocated,
  • Provides diversification and complements broader portfolio allocations, and
  • Has the potential to provide strong risk-adjusted returns .

Private infrastructure’s distinct characteristics are particularly salient in a new investment regime that is biased toward higher interest rate and inflation volatility. Yet, we find that relatively few individual investors have exposure to the asset class. KKR’s wealth-focused asset allocation models consider three potential investor goals: generating income, preserving capital, and boosting returns. Private infrastructure plays a role in achieving all three, with a minimum recommended allocation of 5% (Exhibit 1).

EXHIBIT 1: KKR’s Alternatives Enhanced Framework for Wealth

The KKR Alternatives Enhanced Framework for Wealth shows three model portfolio allocations which focus on the investor goals of generating income, preserving capital and boosting returns.
Source: KKR GBR analysis. Note: Optimization and historical analysis performed on data from 1990-2023, or since available, using the S&P 500 for Public Equities, the Bloomberg Global Aggregate for Fixed Income, the Cambridge Associates Benchmark for Private Equity, the Cliffwater Direct Lending Index for Private Credit, the Cambridge Associate Global Infrastructure Benchmark for Private Infrastructure, and the Cambridge Associates Real Estate Index for Private Real Estate. Income modeled for Public Equity using S&P 500 12M gross dividend yield, Private Equity proxied using S&P Small Cap 12M gross dividend yield, Private Infrastructure proxied using S&P Infrastructure 12M gross dividend yield from 2006-2023 and 1990-2006 back filled using S&P Utilities, Public Credit based on Bloomberg US Agg yield to worst, Private Credit using Cliffwater Direct Lending Index Income Return, Private Real Estate based on Green Street All sector Equal weighted cap rate. Source: Cambridge, Bloomberg, KKR GBR analysis. No specific KKR products referenced.

Private infrastructure can offer both the potential to earn outsized returns and mitigate risk due to its exposure to long-term growth trends through assets that are critical to everyday life. In addition to traditional sectors like utilities and conventional energy, the asset class includes businesses that are critical for long-term energy security (LNG, renewables, and circular economy businesses like energy-from-waste), the digital revolution (fiber optic networks, data centers, and telecom towers), onshoring across industries, and other fast-growing areas of the economy.

Below is some of our analysis on the role private infrastructure can play in investor portfolios.

Strong Performance Relative to Other Asset Classes through the Economic Cycle

Investing in infrastructure, by definition, means investing in the foundation of the evolving real economy. The necessity of infrastructure assets translates into steady cash flows and a degree of resilience when the economic winds are shifting.

Indeed, private infrastructure has historically performed well through the economic cycle. Over the past 10 years, private infrastructure has outperformed every asset class except private equity (Exhibit 2).

EXHIBIT 2: Total Returns by Asset Class (Last 10 Years Through 2Q24)

Line chart showing total returns for various asset classes including private infrastructure and listed infrastructure for the last 10 years.
Note: Analysis using quarterly returns from 2Q14-2Q24. Private Equity, Private Infrastructure, Private Credit, and Private Real Estate refer to the respective Cambridge Associates Benchmark Index and are quoted in net return. Global Equities refers to the MSCI World Index. Listed Infrastructure refers to the S&P Global Infrastructure Index. Global Bonds refers to the Bloomberg Global Agg Index. Global Equities, Listed Infrastructure, and Global Bonds are gross returns. Source: Bloomberg, MSCI, Cambridge Associates, KKR GBR analysis.

An Inflation Hedge that also Performs in Low-Rate Environments

Infrastructure has historically performed well in high inflation periods, but also has attributes that make it attractive when inflation and interest rates are low or falling.

An inflation-hedged asset is similar to a bond with a floating interest rate in that both the hedge and the floating rate become more valuable as inflation and rates rise. Private infrastructure assets are capital-intensive and have intrinsic value. If prices rise in the broader economy, the cost of replacing these assets, including labor, materials, and the cost of debt financing, will likely rise, too. This relationship between the value of hard assets and price movements provides a layer of protection against inflation. In addition, many infrastructure assets have explicit inflation linkages through contracts or regulation, such as regulated utilities or telecom towers that receive rate increases when the consumer price index (CPI) is rising.

Infrastructure’s inherent resistance to inflation, plus the essential nature of the underlying assets, helped it weather the recent high-rate and high-inflation period better than most other traditional inflation hedges during the steepest part of the recent inflationary cycle (Exhibit 3). Our house view is that inflation is likely to stay higher for longer given persistent fiscal deficits, supply chain shifts driven in part by heightened geopolitical tensions, the energy transition, and structural labor shortages.

EXHIBIT 3: Annualized Returns by Asset Class, 4Q2021 – 4Q2022

Bar chart showing annualized returns during the most recent high-rate and high-inflation period from 2021 through 2022.
Source: KKR Global Macro, Balance Sheet & Risk Analysis. Commodities proxied using the S&P GSCI Spot Index, Global Private Infrastructure proxied using the Burgiss Global Infrastructure Index, Private Core Real Estate proxied using the NCREIF Property Index, Publicly Listed Infrastructure proxied using the S&P Global Infrastructure Index, TIPS proxied using the iShares TIPS Bond ETF, US REITS proxied using the MSCI US REIT Index, EU REITS proxied using the MSCI Europe Real Estate Index, U.S. Asset-Backed Securities proxied using the ICE BofA AA-BBB U.S. Asset Backed Securities Index, Bitcoin and Gold spot prices as tracked by Bloomberg. Data as at December 31, 2022. Source: Bloomberg, NCREIF, Burgiss, KKR GBR analysis. No representation is made that the trends depicted or described above will continue.

However, infrastructure does not necessarily suffer in a lower rate environment. Falling rates are typically favorable for equity investors across asset classes, as valuations tend to rise. On the margin, lower borrowing costs can also make constructing entirely new projects, or greenfield development, more attractive. Finally, the steady cash flows infrastructure assets generate tend to produce an attractive cash yield even when rates are low (Exhibit 4)

EXHIBIT 4: The Fed Funds Rate vs. Infrastructure’s Dividend Yield (%)

Line chart showing the Fed Funds Rate versus Infrastructure’s Dividend Yield from 2007 through 2024.
Note: Listed Infrastructure refers to the S&P Global Infrastructure Index. Source: Federal Reserve, Bloomberg, S&P Global.

Lower Volatility even when Broader Markets Are Turbulent and Dislocated

Because infrastructure assets are typically essential to the economy and often have strong local market share, they have historically experienced lower volatility relative to other asset classes, without sacrificing returns (Exhibit 5). In fact, private infrastructure has provided resilient returns even in the largest down markets, particularly relative to other asset classes. This demonstrates the asset class’s ability to provide near-countercyclical performance in some cases and increasingly insulate portfolios from market shocks (Exhibit 6).

EXHIBIT 5: Asset Class Annual Return and Standard Deviation: 2004-2023

Bar chart showing annual return, volatility, and standard deviation for various asset classes from 2004 through 2023.
Data as at 12/30/2023. Private Real Estate modeled using the Cambridge Associates Real Estate Index. Private Infrastructure modeled using the Cambridge Associates Infrastructure Index. Private Equity modeled using the Cambridge Associates Private Equity Index. Private Credit modeled using the Cliffwater Direct Lending Index. Source: KKR GBR.

EXHIBIT 6: Average Quarterly Return 1 Year Prior To-And-During Recessions (2004-2024)

Bar chart showing average quarterly return 1 year prior to-and-during recessions from 2004 through 2024.
Note: Analysis taking the average of the quarterly returns from 1Q04-2Q24 4 quarters before or in quarters defined as recessions by the National Bureau of Economic Research. Private Equity, Private Infrastructure, Private Credit, and Private Real Estate refer to the respective Cambridge Associates Benchmark Index and are quoted in net return. Global Equities refers to the MSCI World Index. Listed Infrastructure refers to the S&P Global Infrastructure Index. Global Bonds refers to the Bloomberg Global Agg Index. Global Equities, Listed Infrastructure, and Global Bonds are gross returns. Source: NBER, Bloomberg, MSCI, Cambridge Associates, KKR GBR analysis.

A Diversifier that Complements other Asset Classes

Given the combination of upside potential, inflation linkages, and insulation from broader volatility, private infrastructure has proven to be a strong diversifier as well. The asset class has low-to-moderate correlation to many other parts of the market (Exhibit 7).

EXHIBIT 7: Return Correlations by Asset Class

Correlation Matrix showing the return correlations for a variety of asset classes include private infrastructure and listed infrastructure.
Note: Analysis using quarterly returns since 1Q04 to 2Q24. Private Equity, Private Infrastructure, Private Credit, and Private Real Estate refer to the respective Cambridge Associates Benchmark Index and are quoted in net return. Global Equities refers to the MSCI World Index. Listed Infrastructure refers to the S&P Global Infrastructure Index. Global Bonds refers to the Bloomberg Global Agg Index. Global Equities, Listed Infrastructure, and Global Bonds are gross returns. Source: Bloomberg, MSCI, Cambridge Associates, KKR GBR analysis.

Potential for Stronger Risk-Adjusted Returns

Ultimately, the characteristics of infrastructure are such that adding it to a traditional 60/40 portfolio would have resulted historically in higher returns with less volatility (Exhibit 8). And clearly not all infrastructure is equal. As Exhibits 3, 6 and 7 demonstrate, private infrastructure has been a more effective inflation hedge, a better performer in turbulent markets, and a more effective diversifier compared to publicly traded infrastructure. Thus, adding private infrastructure would have produced better risk-adjusted returns than adding listed infrastructure.

EXHIBIT 8: Adding Infrastructure Expands the Efficient Frontier

An efficient frontier analysis showing the return and volatility of global equities, global bonds, private infrastructure, public infrastructure and various combinations of the asset classes.
Note: Calculated using annual data from 2004-2023. Global Bonds refers to the Bloomberg Global Agg Index. Global Equities refers to the MSCI World Index. Global Private Infrastructure refers to the Cambridge Private Infrastructure Index. Source: Bloomberg, MSCI, Cambridge, KKR GBR analysis.

We think the reason for these differences is that publicly traded infrastructure investments tend to be concentrated in conventional energy assets, which are susceptible to both economic growth trends and inflation. Private infrastructure tends to have more broad-based exposure across sub-sectors, including some that are much more difficult to access through the public markets.

A Potential Path Forward for Infrastructure in Investor Portfolios

As investors think about incorporating private infrastructure in their portfolios, we think it is helpful to consider its defensive characteristics under several different economic scenarios:

If inflation remains under control and interest rates decline… If inflation remains at current, elevated levels or rises significantly… If macro volatility remains elevated or declines…
Yield becomes increasingly important to investors. Private infrastructure provides an important inflation hedge. Private infrastructure offers long-term, relatively predictable revenue streams with low-to-moderate correlation to other asset classes.
Private infrastructure investments benefit from a lower discount rate.

As we speak to investors around the world, we hear their concerns about relatively high valuations and an increasing level of concentration in public equity markets. As they consider the varying risks associated with a volatile economic and geopolitical backdrop, they are looking for alternatives that can perform through the economic cycle. We believe private infrastructure can help address many of these concerns.


Video Spotlight